At the Forefront of the Burnham Era is the Provincialisation of Power

In British politics, conversations increasingly centre on legitimacy, identity, and political place. The growing significance of regional leadership, local government and civic institutions is paramount to understanding contemporary politics, in which our institutions, cultures, and democracies are in need of exploration. Here, Burnham’s trajectory from Mayor of Greater Manchester to Prime Minister illustrates the competing influences within British populism, while exposing enduring paradoxes surrounding political power, belonging and access. 

As a leader shaped by regional identity and demands for decentralisation, today, he now occupies Britain’s most centralised political office. Coined as Manchesterism, the rhetoric of Manchester's political lens is not simply the city Burnham represents; it has shaped the political language through which he now presents his leadership. Provincialisation is defined as the movement of power away from a dominant centre (and as a critique of power as a singular operative source). So, when applied to Burnham, this raises a peculiar tension: will his regional political experience transform Westminster’s established structures or will his incorporation into national leadership reinforce the same hierarchy he sought to challenge?

Political authority is more than the formal office, and topical to Burnham's politics is his elite educational background, although ironically his regional career has helped cultivate an image of ordinariness and proximity to everyday life. With that being said, compared to his predecessors, he’s among the largest number of cabinet members with a state-school education. In his sphere of influence, Burnham’s Labour invites compelling questions on how leadership is perceived and how formations arise through which politicians today either appear accessible or representative. In this phenomenon, sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (1984) conceptualises this in terms of cultural capital, an outlook that permits understanding of the relationships between social identity, familiarity and authority. 

In Burnham’s transition from regional leadership to national office, several political identities come into focus: the Westminster politician, the city mayor and the prospective British Prime Minister. As he comes into his own, these roles are not necessarily incompatible, but together they raise competing expectations. Undoubtedly, his cultural influence is closely intertwined with his political skill; in this sense, tensions lie between his political character and his capacity to alter the structures within which he governs himself and his political reach, in the structures that showcase both abundance and opportunity for working-class people. In facing this challenge, Burnham’s political authenticity and the merits of his achievements are put to the test.

The politics of place

For power, and in this case, the provincialisation of power, to mean more than a change in political personnel, it must involve a meaningful redistribution of resources, decision-making and accountability. Regional inequality has long shaped Britain’s political landscape; disparities in investment, employment and infrastructure have contributed to political divisions, particularly where economic opportunities have been concentrated primarily in London and the South East of England. Burnham’s political position reflects a broader attempt to challenge Labour’s historically centralised relationship with political power, bringing regional interests and communities closer to national decision-making. Connecting places once seen as far from the political centre as increasingly important areas to how Britain understands its political future, values and distribution of power. 

Philosopher Michel Foucault’s (1979) concept of biopolitics offers a framework for understanding how political power operates through the regulation and management of life, health and welfare. Decisions on housing, education, public services and healthcare are not merely administrative matters; they shape people's opportunities, material security and relationship with the state. Viewed through this lens, Manchesterism takes on broader political significance, extending beyond questions of regional autonomy to encompass how governance shapes everyday life. To draw upon this further, feminist geographies offer a valuable framework in exploring the tensions between geographical identity and political representation. Challenging the notion of place as fixed or self-contained, instead understanding place as relational and continually evolving. Applied to Manchesterism, this perspective invites consideration of whose identities, interests and experiences are represented in its political ambition and whether regional leadership can accommodate the walls of Westminster’s fabric to the diverse communities that constitute it (Doreen Massey, 1994). 

The Burnham era challenges the legitimacy of political authority being concentrated exclusively within Westminster, but this doesn’t automatically resolve the inequalities embedded within British politics and civic institutions. Provincialising power must not only challenge Westminster's institutional dominance but also address the inequalities that shape whose voices are heard and whose interests ultimately inform political decisions. Colin Crouch’s (2004) critique of post-democratic politics is particularly pertinent here. Formal democratic processes, from elections to voting, can remain, while meaningful political influence becomes increasingly concentrated among powerful economic interests and within established political networks. 

Beyond Westminster: a pursuit of governing everyday life

Provincialisation extends to where decisions are made and influenced, and to how governments shape everyday experiences. Prior to Burnham's rise to national political prominence, Westminster-centred politics arguably reflected a narrow set of political priorities, assumptions and sources of authority, limiting the extent to which national policymaking could respond to the lived realities of communities beyond the political centre. 

Now, as Manchester increasingly establishes itself as a prominent governing city, Manchesterism invites and proposes opportunities for political institutions to look inward (and outward): in reconsidering the assumptions inherited from Westminster to engage more directly with the people and places they represent. On a metropolitan scale, Greater Manchester’s public transport system, the Bee Network, is a practical point of entry into the political significance of Manchester’s political reach within Westminster governance. 

The Bee Network’s emphasis on service, connection and community raises broader questions about how political authority is exercised and whose needs shape public services. In this reflection, Greater Manchester’s pursuit of greater control over public services, its relations with public institutions and private business, and its use of devolution in shaping economic development and regeneration are apparent. Yet the significance of these developments lies not simply in the transfer of responsibilities to a regional level, but in whether regional influence - on this scale - can meaningfully affect decisions within investment, public services and local priorities. By contrast, Manchesterism offers a different point of reference, bringing regional experience and place-based governance into the critique of Westminster's established structures of political power. For Westminster, this should come with a greater emphasis on local conditions, collective responsibilities and the relationship between political decisions, cities and the communities they affect. 

For Burnham, securing financial investment through an economic model that’s non-London-centric is an important starting point. Its wider significance lies in the capacity to connect economic development with the needs and capacities of particular communities, as seen through Greater Manchester’s expertise in bringing together industry, business, local government, universities, and public institutions. In this model of place-based leadership, Manchester's reputation for urban economic development represents not only a changing economic landscape, but also a political opportunity to explore new avenues of investment and growth in the post-Brexit context. In progressing forward, Labour needs to establish a political case that combines economic opportunity with dignity, participation and public trust. Nevertheless, Burnham’s mission is to actively tie this to socialist and liberal values both in his leadership and with regard to managing responsibility. In summary, it's what that growth is for, who gets to shape it and whether its benefits reach beyond established centres of wealth and influence. Without doing so, changes to the underlying distribution of resources and power, a promise of renewal risks reproducing familiar inequalities under a different political language. 

A provincialisation of power—a new centre or the decentering of the centre? 

Regionalisation does not mean political isolation: local and regional governments operate within wider systems of national and international authority. Burnham’s rise and regional experience can perhaps further raise questions of how political decisions can remain responsive to the people affected by them, rather than allowing power to become concentrated within the institutions that exercise it. 

Provincialisation, in this sense, should not be understood as a straightforward transfer of power from Westminster to regional government, but as a reconsideration of how political authority is distributed and exercised across different levels of governance. This also includes the transfers of power from the political landscapes of Manchester to the political institutions of Westminster, national government, policy, and political ideology. 

Burnham’s political trajectory from Mayor to Prime Minister brings the relationships between local, national, and international politics into a renewed focus. His regional experience will shape how he approaches this, but now he must lead within an established culture of institutional hierarchy. His position at the centre of government may offer greater opportunities to redistribute political authority, while simultaneously exposing the constraints of doing so, both through his own prior experience, in his current political trajectory and within the wider political field. A post-Brexit domain further complicates this picture. Although political authority can be redistributed within the UK, domestic decisions remain shaped by international markets, institutions, legal obligations and geopolitical developments. 

Climate change, economic security, international law and conflict all influence domestic political debate. Questions of humanitarian responsibility and Palestinian state recognition may emerge internationally, but they also test the values, priorities and accountability of political institutions within British politics. 

Subsequently, as Labour moves forward in opposing the genocide of the Palestinian people, in support of Palestinian self-determination, and Palestinian statehood, it is a distinct context in which to examine the relationships between recognition, political capacity and realisation. The comparisons do not equate regional politics in Britain with Palestinian liberation. Rather, it asks a more limited question: under what conditions does political recognition translate into the practical capacity to shape progressive political outcomes? Across both cases, the distinction between legitimacy and effective power provides a framework for examining the possibilities of political change without presuming its political sovereignty and livelihood. 

Getting Back into the Room

The relationship between Manchester and Westminster illustrates the multi-scalar and reciprocal processes of political power. The significance of these relationships lies not simply in where power is exercised, but in whether they make accountability more effective, democracy more meaningful and freedom more tangible in people’s everyday lives. 

In Burnham’s political trajectory, possibilities are brought into focus without fully resolving them; regional influence can shape national governance, while central institutions can constrain both regional and political autonomy. The remaining challenge is to confront the constraints of existing political structures: as Mayor of Greater Manchester, devolution provided a foundation for this depiction, but as Prime Minister, can provincialising power allow for a reconsideration of how political power is exercised? 

Applied to the Labour Party, the question is not simply who occupies the political centre, but in questioning whether the centre can be reconfigured. Against this backdrop, Burnham’s regional experience opens up new possibilities for the Labour Party’s renewal, offering a basis for reconsidering how the party represents itself, the working class and its political values. 

Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor’s End Times Fascism: And the Fight for the Living World (2026) provides a broader perspective on the political possibilities that emerge during periods of crisis. Instabilities can create exclusion and anti-social concentrations of power; alternatively, they can also open space for democratic renewal, collective action and solidarity. The course of political change is not assumed in advance; it depends on institutions, movements, and political actors responding to these conditions. This becomes particularly relevant as we enter the terrains of Westminster and Manchesterism or, in a profoundly different context, the international recognition of Palestinian statehood, the right to Palestinian self-determination and the liberty of Palestinian governance. These distinctions help illuminate how political power operates, as well as the challenges of translating progressive political aspirations into forms of governance supported by the institutional and material conditions that are necessary for realisation. It is here that legitimacy, extending beyond representation alone, becomes central to the constitution of effective political power.


Written by Malaika Fallah

Malaika Fallah is a writer at the intersection of politics, philosophy, and culture. Her work explores identity, belonging, and power through the lenses of geography, queer theory, and lived experience. 

PoliticsJessica Blackwell